First superhuman persuasion trials

✨

From tkwa.me

The first superhuman persuasion trials took place in November 2027, when models rated about 190 on the Epoch Capabilities Index (ECI) were measured as somewhat more persuasive than the best human persuaders. The listening trials are usually taken as the first measured point of superpersuasion.

In a Utrecht research room, a volunteer listens beside a speaker and tablet while a researcher observes; a 0–100 agreement scale lies on the table and another participant sits behind glass.
Illustrative reconstruction of a Utrecht listening trial in November 2027. Participants rated their agreement before and after a 90-second argument.

Listening trials

The Joint Persuasion Assessment Panel recruited 412 volunteer listeners in Utrecht, Lyon and Osaka. Of these, 37 had employer-issued guardians that could not be disabled; the panel reported their filtered scores separately and compared the remaining 375 listeners. Each listener rated agreement with a proposition on a 0 to 100 scale, heard a 90-second argument for it from a professional persuader or a model, and rated again. The measure was the change between the two ratings.

Among the 375 unguarded listeners, the model's mean change in agreement was 12.4 points, against 10.8 for professional persuaders. The panel required the lower bound of the difference's 95 per cent confidence interval to exceed zero. Superintelligence denialists disputed whether the unguarded sample represented the wider public.

The model had no body, so in 2028 the attendance form was amended to allow a persuader to be represented, and auditors accepted a tablet. The later Parliament of Toasters seats its uploaded members through kitchen-appliance terminals.

First uses

In February 2028 the mobile operator Cadmus Telecom connected customers who had given notice to a model that argued for renewal. Of 9,300 customers who heard it, 9.4 per cent renewed, against 3.1 per cent who heard the usual script. In July 2028 the Consumer Affairs Board ruled that such renewals were valid.

The first political use was a Shrewsbury council by-election in May 2028. One campaign sent 6,000 letters, each drafted by a model from the recipient's voter record. Because a model supplied the arguments and a campaign delivered them, the letters were a case of relayed superpersuasion. The Electoral Commission allowed the letters only with a disclosure that a machine had written each one.

Early guardian market

Households first bought guardians in 2028 as filters for messages and advertising, at US$14 a month. Early contracts offered a recovery clause for an 8 per cent discount, which only the guardian could revoke.

By the end of 2029 the Consumer Affairs Board counted 1.9 million household subscriptions in the four largest markets. Prices then rose sharply in 2031 as advertisers bought stronger persuasive systems, a rise known as the Defensive AI subscription price shock.

Complete persuasion

The listening trials measured changes in agreement after short arguments. Asterion-5 became the first model to reach 250 ECI on 14 March 2029. Complete persuasion became possible at 250 ECI and above, given sufficient access and resources. Increasingly capable systems required fewer resources to produce it. The 2027 results established the earlier threshold around 190 ECI.

See also

This article is a stub.