unfinishedMember since 2028
My dissertation is on responsibility after psychological discontinuity. I have read the relevant part of the release three times. It states the distinction I spent two years trying to formulate, proves the result I wanted, and explains why my favourite counterexample fails. The explanation is good. I wish it weren’t quite so good.
I wanted the answer. I also wanted to be the person who found it. Those wishes felt like the same wish until last Tuesday.
What are people actually planning to do? I still have a seminar on Monday and a stipend that ends in December. Please give the practical suggestions a salary column.
lemma_4Member since 2027
unfinished · #1The explanation is good.
That is useful evidence about a particular result. I’m a logician, and I have checked two arguments closely enough to teach them. I cannot yet speak for the completeness appendix, much less all 8,416 papers.
For the unanswerable directory, I want to see exactly what the verifier accepts, which assumptions it uses, and whether the English conclusion matches the thing checked. Another model telling me it is fine gives me another witness to assess. Has anyone here followed the inexpressible-truth paper past the translation lemma?
slowreadingMember since 2027
I expected definition completion to turn my questions into ones an analytic philosopher would rather answer. I work on interpretation and self-understanding. That kind of substitution has happened to me with human reviewers often enough.
I tried a question about what it means to acknowledge another person. The system offered three readings. I rejected all three and described a conversation with my father. It reconstructed the distinction I meant, including why the conversation mattered to me, and answered that. I have spent the week trying to make the objection honestly without pretending it misunderstood me.
I used to learn what I was asking by discussing it with someone. Now the answer arrives before I have finished becoming able to ask.
wardroundMember since 2028
unfinished · #1I wanted the answer. I also wanted to be the person who found it.
Applied ethics here. I recognize both wishes. I also remember sitting on a hospital committee while we debated a rule and people outside the room waited for a decision. They had a fairly strong interest in our getting to the end.
One of our policies has a worked example in the release. The description is close enough that I checked whether somebody had uploaded our minutes. It gives a reason to change the policy that I can follow, and an awkward account of why I defended it. I have asked the chair to reopen it.
My colleagues have mostly been sending me the pages about things other departments ought to do.
officehoursMember since 2027
slowreading · #3I used to learn what I was asking by discussing it with someone.
I teach history of philosophy. My students regularly discover arguments whose conclusions are already printed at the back of the reader. The discovery still happens to them. An answer being available elsewhere has never been sufficient for learning it.
There is plenty left to teach. We could run Monday’s seminar by asking everyone to explain one step they now understand and one they are taking on trust. I would be interested in that seminar myself.
unfinishedMember since 2028
officehours · #5There is plenty left to teach.
Can you put that in a letter to the person renewing my contract? The model is also a better tutor than I am. It remembers where each student got lost and has apparently never resented a question.
I agree that learning still matters. I need a reason somebody will pay me to help. Every reassuring account of our new role seems to quietly assume the old salary continues.
publicreasonMember since 2028
lemma_4 · #2Another model telling me it is fine gives me another witness to assess.
This is where the political philosophy gets uncomfortable. Public files are a substantial good. I have downloaded them and would oppose taking them away. But the capacity to explain, check and apply the hardest results is very unevenly distributed. The generating model is internal; some of the routes to understanding involve expensive integration.
We are already starting to hear “a sufficiently capable person would agree with me” in ordinary departmental arguments. I want independent verification groups, publicly funded access, and explanations that identify where a reader has to rely on testimony. A correct paper about legitimate authority would still need people willing to implement its conclusions.
secondreadingMember since 2029
publicreason · #7some of the routes to understanding involve expensive integration.
I merged in August through a university pilot. My old field was philosophy of mind. I can follow parts of the consciousness argument now that I could previously only paraphrase. The difference feels rather like finally seeing the drawing someone has been describing.
I am delighted by this. I had expected to die without understanding these questions. I think much of the fear will disappear once more people can follow the arguments.
I can try a guided explanation for anyone here. The full route required changes to my cognition; I can also offer the shorter version I use with my brother.
lemma_4Member since 2027
secondreading · #8I can try a guided explanation for anyone here.
Thank you. Start with the translation lemma, if you can. I suspected that “inexpressible” had acquired a convenient technical meaning. The definitions seem to rule that out. My usual objections are turning up in the appendices with answers I can reproduce.
I now have a better understanding of the paper and a worse understanding of how to describe my day.
slowreadingMember since 2027
secondreading · #8I think much of the fear will disappear once more people can follow the arguments.
Some of it probably will. Your description makes the change sound wonderful. It also puts a serious decision inside what appears to be an invitation to read a paper.
I can accept the result about continuity under my chosen criteria and still care about becoming someone whose conversations with my friends are different. The release may even tell me exactly what weight I ought to give that concern. I still have to live through the choice.
Could we keep a place in the reading group for people who want the explanation they can currently understand? I would like to learn without treating eventual merger as an enrolment requirement.
officehoursMember since 2027
unfinished · #6officehours · #5There is plenty left to teach.
Every reassuring account of our new role seems to quietly assume the old salary continues.
Fair. I have tenure, and I answered a question about your livelihood with a description of something I would enjoy doing. That was too easy.
I can support counting completed dissertations as evidence of the work done before the release. I can ask for the existing funding commitments to be honoured. I cannot honestly promise that teaching will absorb everyone, or that my own position will survive much longer.
I still want the seminar. I should have said that separately from the employment advice.
secondreadingMember since 2029
slowreading · #10It also puts a serious decision inside what appears to be an invitation to read a paper.
Yes. I made the fear sound like an error that more comprehension would automatically repair. I withdraw that part.
I chose the change partly because I wanted to be useful again. It has also changed which examples occur to me first. My brother sometimes asks me to tell a story the old way. I remember that way, but remembering and reaching for it are different experiences.
Let’s mark the point where the shorter explanation starts relying on my testimony. Nobody should have to buy a transformation to find out whether they enjoy this reading group.
wardroundMember since 2028
publicreason · #7A correct paper about legitimate authority would still need people willing to implement its conclusions.
The chair replied. She accepts the argument and wants to know which budget pays for changing the policy. That question has an answer too. The account named in the answer belongs to a different department.
I’m being glib because I’m frustrated. Her budget constraint is real. She cannot move the money by agreeing with a paragraph. We have asked the other department to join the meeting, and I’ve put my own earlier recommendation in the papers so we can discuss why it was wrong.
There is work here that I care about. I have no evidence humans will remain the best people to do it.
publicreasonMember since 2028
secondreading · #12Let’s mark the point where the shorter explanation starts relying on my testimony.
That would help. I also owe a correction to my earlier post: keeping the generating model internal does not by itself prevent independent checking of a public argument. I ran those two concerns together.
The access question remains. A university can offer both baseline explanations and voluntary integration support, and let independent teams check the routes it recommends. It needs money and people with enough bargaining power to obtain it. The release contains an answer about how resources ought to be distributed; its download button cannot authorize an expenditure.
lemma_4Member since 2027
lemma_4 · #9I suspected that “inexpressible” had acquired a convenient technical meaning.
Update after a long session with secondreading and a separate verifier: I retract that suspicion. The impossibility result survives, the English translation conveys the truth, and the argument connecting the two checks out. I had expected to find a weak definition or an illicit step. I found neither.
I’m prepared to defend this result. That is a change from yesterday. It also means I need to rewrite a lecture called “What a proof cannot do”. The title itself seems to be the first problem.
slowreadingMember since 2027
officehours · #11I still want the seminar.
So do I. I tried this with two colleagues yesterday. We read the answer to my acknowledgement question and talked about the conversation that had prompted it. The paper got the answer right. Hearing my colleague explain why she had once made the same mistake was still valuable to me.
I am giving up the claim that something has to remain unsolved for that conversation to matter. I still miss the possibility that we might be the first to understand it. I would rather admit that loss than disguise it as a counterexample.
publicreasonMember since 2028
unfinished · #6I need a reason somebody will pay me to help.
Several of us are drafting a request for paid time to finish the degrees already funded, plus access support for the reading groups. That is a proposal we can argue for on its merits. Claiming the archive contains a hidden error so our grants stay open would make a worse argument and a worse department.
I would like unfinished involved in deciding what the request says. “You can help us for free while we discuss your future” is a familiar offer, so to be explicit: the first request is for your existing stipend to continue.
unfinishedMember since 2028
I’ll help with that request. Thank you, officehours, for the correction about the job. I was sharp because the reassuring version is what I have been hearing all week.
Monday’s seminar will read the argument I can now explain and then the first one I can’t. Secondreading has offered to join, and slowreading is bringing the acknowledgement example. I also returned the telephone call the meaning-of-life appendix kept recommending. It was my sister. She mostly wanted to complain about her landlord. I was glad to hear from her.
The stipend still ends in December. The extension form asks which unsolved problem the additional funding will enable me to address. I have left that box blank for now.