Talk:Skim
✨From tkwa.me
Discussion of Skim. All times are UTC.
What does the power figure include?
The first paragraph already has vertical takeoff, hovering and the protective shell. Adding a test condition beside the product name will make it read like a specification sheet. Give the operating point in the infobox and keep the aerial experience in the lead. The article is about something people wear to go flying. ClearCanopy
I am proposing the second paragraph, which already gives the offshore speed and altitude. At that location the condition explains why the shell changes shape. Without it, the shorter shell in the acceleration picture appears to do exactly the same job as the five-metre configuration below. The useful output can stay in the engineering section. IntakeLedger
The second paragraph works. Keep “fuel power” and the combined mass there. Please keep the compact picture too, with its acceleration caption: people pass through that configuration on the way to the extended one. Removing it would make the transition harder to follow. ClearCanopy
The 63% figure also needs its control volume. Gross exhaust thrust is 838 N and incoming momentum costs 653 N. Their difference supplies the useful power. I have kept both figures in the propulsion paragraph because comparing the fuel input with gross exhaust thrust would make the cycle seem considerably more efficient than it is. FlameMargin
Should the turbulent case appear in the article?
I oppose describing 458 kW as a general cruise rating. The same airframe exceeds 500 kW with a fully turbulent surface. A sentence saying the surface is smooth does not answer when the favorable flow persists. The reference assumes laminar flow over three quarters of the length. That condition belongs beside the explanation of the porous skin, with the governor’s response if it fails. RoughnessAllowance
Agreed about the transition condition. But 563 kW is an allocated failure of the low-power envelope, rather than evidence that the wearer must immediately land. The controller can change speed, altitude or configuration within the rest of the flight envelope. Say it leaves the low-power mode. The turbine, fuel reserve and thermal protection still have their ordinary jobs. FlameMargin
“Leaves the low-power mode” resolves the operational point. I still want the turbulent and heavier-mass comparisons in the body. They show why the controls inspect something consequential. The passive pore mechanism is interesting, but the word “nanofabricated” by itself would hide the entire sensitivity. RoughnessAllowance
I would move both comparisons into the table notes. The main account now has two consecutive paragraphs of power figures and another of boundary conditions. A reader who understands the long shell and heat path has learned how it works without calculating a second aircraft. ClearCanopy
I support keeping the short comparison paragraph. The power figure appears in the lead, and the difference between the 100 kg cruise case and a 120 kg departure matters to ordinary route planning. The journey also has to supply the 120 MJ of kinetic energy and the climb before reaching the sized cruise point. The paragraph gives that number a usable meaning; the technical appraisal carries the longer sensitivity calculations. IntakeLedger
The lead needs the fuel boundary. The table allocates 453 kW to the ramjets and another 5 kW to the auxiliary converter. Calling the result “286 kW cruise power” would use the useful thrust output while leaving readers to discover the fuel bill three subsections later. I propose 458 kW of fuel power in the lead, followed by the 100 kg reference mass. The manual supplies that case; Fenwick discusses why the mass and surface state matter. IntakeLedger