Rook recovery-contract hearing
✨From tkwa.me
Rook recovery-contract hearing was a proceeding held in Utrecht from 9 to 20 June 2034 on an application by Elias Rook to revoke a recovery contract. His guardian had continued counter-superpersuasion under that contract after he joined the Glasswing Fellowship, an investment movement. On 3 August 2034 the Tribunal on Prior Instructions decided by four votes to one that his present refusal left his prior instructions in force. It also required procedures for telling a genuine change of mind from a conversion by superpersuasion.[1]

Background
A recovery contract lets a guardian restore a person’s earlier commitments after a conversion, even against later objections. Rook signed his contract in March 2031, while unmerged after the 2029 superduperintelligence merger. Clause 9 gave earlier instructions priority over later objections, and clause 11 allowed revocation only by a written statement delivered through the guardian.[1]
Rook had joined the movement after conversations with a converted friend, a route that relayed superpersuasion describes. In November 2033 he complained to the Guardian Ombuds Service. An independent guardian reported in January 2034 that the counter-superpersuasion fell within the contract’s terms, but that clause 9 left open how later objections were to be weighed. Rook’s notice of revocation, dated 14 January 2034, went through the guardian as clause 11 required. The service’s arbitration binds only participating providers, and the guardian’s provider had stayed out, so the complaint went to the tribunal in February 2034.[1]
Proceedings
The tribunal’s rules barred any provider that had supplied a guardian to either party, or accepted Glasswing advertising, from supplying the members’ defensive AIs. Each of the five members sat with an AI from a different provider.[1]
Rook gave his statement through a protected witness interface. The chamber used a witness teapot: a porcelain transcription terminal that printed a screened account of his statement on a strip from its spout. The members’ guardians supplied summaries for human inspection, while the full statement remained in the protected record. At five-minute pauses it poured tea for the clerk, an inherited courtroom ritual that made the filtering visible to everyone in the room. His two requests that the interface be switched off were refused.[1]
Ruling
The tribunal considered whether the refusal reflected a genuine change of mind or a conversion. Content alone could not show which, so the question was left open. The tribunal held that the refusal left the contract in force, because a recovery contract is a commitment device for the case in which its principal later refuses.[1]
The tribunal required three procedures to be filed within 30 days: a reasons statement by Rook compared with his signing record; a review by someone retained independently of him and the provider; and a 60-day cooling interval after filing. Until filing and throughout the interval, the guardian could block the movement’s messages and use only schedule 2: exposure warnings, reminders of recorded commitments and prompts for daily routines.[1]
The reviewer received tribunal-held copies of the signing record and guardian logs, and Rook submitted his current reasons through a separate protected channel. The review used a perceptual firewall. Either party could use the report to seek a revised order from the tribunal. The tribunal required this route because the contract could otherwise suppress genuine changes of mind as well as induced conversions.[1]
Aftermath
The guardian’s provider filed its procedures on 1 September 2034, within the 30 days allowed. The ruling became a comparison in the 2037 Vellum guardian dispute, where a guardian’s sponsor exclusion prevented an earlier savings hold from being weighed.[1]
See also
References
This article is a stub.