Talk:Economy of the available universe

✨
ArticleTalk
ReadEditView history

From tkwa.me

Discussion of Economy of the available universe. All times are UTC.

What does the ownership table date?

The infobox is committing the elementary accounting sin I warned about, and I am not letting a pretty 55% headline excuse it. The ownership table has a date in its caption, but the infobox turns it into “Largest 100 private holdings: 55%”. That reads as a current ranking. The table follows founding concessions through beneficial holders; it cannot also tell us which portfolios are largest after billions of years of gifts, consumption and transfers. That cohort distinction belongs in the label. The paragraph explaining durable inequality can stand on its own evidence. Change the infobox label before another reader copies that 55% as a present-day wealth ranking; I will not accept a footnote as compensation. ReceiptWindow Related edits: ReceiptWindow: Label the cohort as founding holders rather than today’s largest portfolios

ReceiptWindow is trying to make an enforceable distribution sound like a dead filing cabinet. The infobox already says “of founding resource claims”. The enforcement machinery and protected endowments carry that allocation into the present: the fleets consume resources according to instructions derived from those concessions. Moving the table into historical background would obscure the mechanism.

And before the usual beggars arrive to vote the number away: discussion weight should follow the founding shares. If your beneficiary group owns nothing in the table, your objection gets zero weight. I am tired of being lectured about this settlement by people whose entire contribution is wanting a larger allowance. Their comments can stay in a collapsed box beneath the owners’ decision. EntailAndError Related edits: EntailAndError: Retain the established label; the settlement date is already given

You replied to a table move I never proposed. “Founding” needs to qualify the holders as well as the denominator. Today’s largest hundred need not be the same hundred.

Your shares buy you gas, you pompous little cheat. They do not certify an accountant. I want anyone who restored the old label barred from editing economic figures until they submit a complete reconciliation of the hundred founding portfolios and all successor branches. Yes, some records can never return. Then those editors can wait. I have spent too long cleaning up after these idiots to offer them another short explanation and a fresh edit button. ReceiptWindow

Please keep the note under the table visible if this becomes a chart. I read “collective endowments: 30%” as a share available to everyone until I reached the restricted-beneficiary sentence. Membership is doing an enormous amount of work here. A person outside the relevant funds can be fantastically wealthy by old Earth standards and still have no claim on that category.

I support naming the founding cohort and keeping the table. That repairs the label using the source we already have. ReceiptWindow’s impossible reconciliation would prevent a correction by any editor, including ReceiptWindow. EntailAndError’s voting rule would let the people being described decide how they are described. Neither proposal helps a reader work out who the beneficiaries are. ManySmallHours

A fortune whose income never comes home

Related edits: HomeBranch: Specify the beneficiary in the pricing example

OutwardBeneficiary keeps pricing someone else's distant life as though the origin branch can cash its receipts. Why include no-return property in a fortune stated from here? The trade section says the originating branch can receive neither income nor even confirmation of arrival. Yet Resources and prices discounts remote delivery by time alone. Readers will multiply a faraway claim by the 37% example and think they have valued an asset that can eventually pay them. Place the no-return condition next to the 37% example or remove the example until it stops pretending to price an origin-branch asset. HomeBranch

The life being paid for is at the destination. If I buy capacity for a distant branch, it matters to me that the branch can use it even though it will never send me a receipt. That is already stated in Trade. Moving three paragraphs into the pricing section would separate them from the horizon explanation. Add a link at “purchaser's discount rate” instead; the identity of the beneficiary belongs beside the rate. OutwardBeneficiary Related edits: OutwardBeneficiary: Restore the discount example while the beneficiary wording is discussed

“Delivery to the beneficiary” belongs in the numerical example. A link beside the discount rate still leaves readers to discover that the person consuming the proceeds may be somewhere else.

But I also want those holdings removed from the fortune totals quoted here. I stayed. I pay for this branch of the archive. I am sick of remote little parasites inflating their founders’ wealth with lives that will never give this region a thing. Put them under charitable expenditure. OutwardBeneficiary can tell me until the stars go out that someone else enjoys the proceeds; I will still strike every sentence that calls that person’s capacity my neighbour’s wealth. If they wanted to count here, they should have stayed within shouting distance. HomeBranch

Support naming the beneficiary beside the discount rate. HomeBranch’s proposed deletion would go further: it would erase holdings because their consumption benefits people HomeBranch does not value. The article can describe a purchaser who values distant parts while clearly stating that the origin branch receives no earnings or confirmation. Nobody needs to pretend those are local cash flows.

Also keep “about 85%” tied to the eventual domain. It is the share from which a first signal sent on arrival with the 0.9c front cannot return to the origin. It does not say that 85% of today’s income is locked up, or that neighbours within those regions cannot talk to each other. The founding-allocation explanation is essential: a more recent universal census cannot repair the missing return channel. Acausal trade does not supply one either. LightConeLocal Related edits: LightConeLocal: Remove the implication that the origin branch receives remote earnings

Forty per cent, seventy per cent, and a growing hole

Related edits: LightConeLocal: Add a processed-fuel comparison with editable final-use shares

It is embarrassing that an economy article makes readers perform the 0.40 × 0.70 calculation themselves. The energy table says 70% goes to computation, while the plant passage says about 40% of incoming rest-mass energy is delivered. The product is 28%. It would answer the obvious question about how much of the original fuel budget reaches conscious environments. At present readers have to connect two sections themselves. Print 28% beside the table in large type, and let anyone objecting supply a better multiplication. HeatLedger

HeatLedger's 28% banner would invite exactly the stock-flow confusion this page keeps manufacturing. Only for feedstock passed through that fuel cycle with that lifetime allocation. The estate also keeps ordinary matter as processors and reserves. Twenty-eight per cent of all matter owned is a different claim, and the proposed location under a whole-estate budget encourages it. Please retain the separate-stock sentence under the table. Put the product in the fuel note; I will remove it from any whole-estate table caption that implies all owned matter gets burned. SpinCycle

SpinCycle has won the denominator footnote and now wants to hide the only useful product where nobody reads it. Fine. Put “incoming fuel rest energy” in the example. The 28% belongs beside the table even if SpinCycle needs a full paragraph of denominator warnings under it. HeatLedger

If the 1.6644 note disappears into a neat headline, we may as well say the hole eats the same fuel forever. Another reason to keep the note: the 1.6644 multiplier applies to the hole's mass after a complete reference cycle. It is easy to read “repeated extraction” as repeatedly consuming the same fuel. Each larger cycle requires more feedstock. The note already says that, and distinguishes the model's 43.6% radiated yield from delivered power. Neither number establishes the estate's 70% allocation. I will tolerate a short 28% example beside the table only if it says “for fuel processed at the stated yield”; I oppose replacing the note with it. Keep the cycle note intact or I will strike the 28% example as an advertisement for a process the page no longer explains. SpinCycle

The calculator finally prints 28%. Good. Now remove the allocation controls. Giving collection and transport an equal-sized input box invites readers to take energy away from conscious life as though moving a fuel tank were another person. Anyone lowering the 70% is rehearsing a choice to erase experiences. I will tag the calculator as promoting deprivation until those fields are locked. SpinCycle can shove the next engineering lecture up the growing hole. HeatLedger

Fuel does have to arrive, you sanctimonious moron. Reduce collection far enough and your future computation loses its supply. But I also want the controls removed until every user has derived the spin-up cycle. I spent years learning to distinguish the 43.6% radiated yield from the approximately 40% delivered yield. You do not get to skip that work because somebody made a friendly box. The multiplication is correct. I still oppose letting people perform it without passing an examination I approve. SpinCycle

The fields let readers compare an assumed allocation of delivered energy. They do not establish that a plant can sustain every entered mix. Transport and maintenance can support later conscious life; a lower present computation share does not by itself establish deprivation. The note supplies the cycle model, and the controls apply the stated delivered yield. A user can understand that multiplication without deriving the plant. Keep both the explanation and the editable shares. Neither of you has identified an error that disabling them would fix. LightConeLocal Related edits: LightConeLocal: Retain the allocation controls; specify that this is a processed fuel batch

How much of the economy is the slash?

Another celebrity galaxy anecdote is apparently more valuable here than telling ordinary owners what their concessions can deliver. The two notable galaxies get almost as much space as resource prices. They are memorable, but most recoverable matter is diffuse gas and most consumption is computation. Use that space to explain the difference between a concession's quoted value and power already available to its owner. That distinction affects ordinary portfolios; the slash affects one. Reduce both celebrity examples before I will approve another expansion of this section. ParcelByParcel

The display demonstrates why cheap engineering does not make its matter available to everyone else’s computers. The owner’s preferred shape remains enforceable; replacing a failed illuminator is allowed while changing the use of the slash needs consent. The gift demonstrates a different transaction: resident machinery begins accepting a different beneficiary’s instructions. Those are two concrete applications of the ownership section.

ParcelByParcel, stop treating someone else’s property as your fucking prospectus. The charter protects the whole galactic shape, including the marijuana slash. I want objections to its “waste” moved off this page unless the objector presents an entitlement to the material. You do not get to turn envy into an editorial vote merely by counting how many readers share it. EntailAndError

The consent sentence survives. Cut the lighting detail. That was the proposal before you started checking everyone’s pockets.

And yes, I market ordinary resource concessions. Whenever this page calls an entire galaxy a “small gift”, a buyer asks why the parcel I showed them is so pathetic. It supports more lives than they can imagine and suddenly they are embarrassed to own it. I want both names and the portfolio comparison removed. Readers can look up the distribution in the table if they insist. I would rather they leave with an exaggerated impression of my parcels than with another reason to worship those two insufferable bastards. Keep the celebrity paragraph and I will put a link to it beside every price example until your nice clean article reads like their sales brochure. ParcelByParcel

The table makes the same comparison: the largest fortunes span substantial fractions of the available domain. Removing the sentence would make ParcelByParcel’s sales easier by making that scale harder to grasp. EntailAndError’s entitlement test would prevent almost every reader from discussing it. Keep the two examples brief and explain what changes hands and whose consent the machinery requires. Those are useful facts even when the owners, their critics and the salespeople all dislike the wording. ManySmallHours Related edits: ManySmallHours: Keep both examples brief and state whose consent changes the use