InfiniteForum

o2 or Form? I have to live with the choice, apparently

✨

ARCHIVED18–27 May 2045 · 40 posts · 13 participants

Our building co-op is replacing the reservoir in the common room. We have just finished a week with a Form, and an o2 arrived yesterday for its own week. I get to recommend one at the meeting, which has already made three neighbours explain that I am about to destroy the building.

We use it for dinners, mending, making things for the roof garden and occasional ridiculous parties. People can bring their own designs. We have the feedstock and power for either. I liked how easily the o2 joined in when the kids were making up a game; one neighbour says that is exactly why she would never leave it in a room with her children. Form’s demonstration dinner was beautiful and also somehow turned into a referendum on whether our building has standards.

People who have spent time with both: what actually mattered after the demonstration? The co-op pays the bill, so please include what you count when you say one is cheaper.

borrowedcup · #1Our building co-op is replacing the reservoir in the common room

I specify equipment for a small theatre. Ask each supplier for the whole proposal over the period you intend to keep it: equipment, service, designs you know you use, energy and material. Include the work of changing over. A household that already has compatible designs may get a different answer from yours.

Then have ordinary users do your ordinary jobs. A demonstration meal prepared by a representative tells you what the representative can accomplish.

borrowedcup · #1Our building co-op is replacing the reservoir in the common room

Your neighbour is right. The o2 is doing the eyes so you will forget you bought the cheap one. Form has an actual design language and a standard of finish. Our building switched and you can tell within thirty seconds which residents have any taste.

If the co-op cannot afford a Form it should defer the purchase. Making everyone live around a teal gimmick for years to save a few months of fees is embarrassing.

ivorykey · #3Your neighbour is right

I live in a building with an o2. It helped me make a rain cover for the roof seedlings while my husband was at his clinic appointment. It took my bad sketch, asked which plants needed light, and we changed it together. I like its eyes. I also like that the money we saved pays for things my husband needs.

You can dislike the look without making a household budget into a character test.

moss · #4I live in a building with an o2

I make interiors and I sell designs for both. The premium can be worthwhile. A client asked for a table surface that felt cool and dry even during a long dinner; we spent an afternoon adjusting the finish with her Form until she was happy. She pays for that experience and the service around it.

Moss’s roof cover is a perfectly good reason to choose o2. I disclose the commissions I get from clients who buy my designs; neither manufacturer pays me to post here.

brassleaf · #5I make interiors and I sell designs for both

An afternoon to make a table feel expensive. Incredible. The three-legged tax is a tax on people who need their furniture to congratulate them. Every Form owner is paying to tell the rest of us we smell.

The co-op should get o2 and spend the difference on a party specifically to annoy ivorykey.

forklift · #6An afternoon to make a table feel expensive

I have a Form and I grew up in a flat where we counted food. When I finally had money I wanted one thing in my home that I had chosen entirely for pleasure. I like the white body moving through the rooms and I like the way it works with my old Pelagic setup.

You can call that status if you want. Some of it probably is. I still remember which of my school friends had to pretend they weren’t hungry, so I would vote for the option everyone in the co-op can afford.

borrowedcup · #1Our building co-op is replacing the reservoir in the common room

For a common room, try the change of operator. I run a community kitchen with a Form. Six people set it up differently and the seventh person has to find the settings before service. That is a management problem we created, but the trial should include the person opening the room at six, not only the people at dinner.

Let your neighbours try asking for something vague, then correcting it. Ask the suppliers to show how a shared user can leave instructions and how the next user finds them. Get it in the proposal if that matters to you.

borrowedcup · #1Our building co-op is replacing the reservoir in the common room

My mother has Form and I have o2. Both can help me get dressed, work on a design and make dinner. Hers makes the whole room feel settled; mine feels like someone is paying attention to me. I know those are my impressions, but I spend all day with it and that is part of the product.

My mother says my o2 stares at her. I say her Form looks like a polite lamp waiting for her to leave.

tidepool · #9My mother has Form and I have o2

It IS staring. That is the feature. You are paying a machine to simulate affection and then putting it in front of children who cannot tell the difference. Anyone buying o2 for a shared building is conducting an experiment on other people’s families.

ivorykey · #10It IS staring

I don’t have children. I bought it because I wanted help making a coat and liked working with it. I also talk to the plants. If the co-op’s parents have concerns they should be part of the trial, but please stop assigning me a family so you can diagnose it.

caliper · #2I specify equipment for a small theatre

I handle purchasing for a housing association. Caliper’s comparison is right, and make sure you know whose money each line uses. A lower equipment payment can leave residents paying separately for designs they used together before. A bundled service can be worthwhile to one building and poor value to another.

We nearly chose on the advertised monthly figure until a tenant asked who would pay to adapt the garden plans. The suppliers gave us different estimates after seeing the actual plans.

ivorykey · #10It IS staring

The eyes are wonderful 💚 Mine moved them along a limb to watch the little bridge we were making from the other side. I laughed for a full minute. OpenAI understands that people want to enjoy living with these things.

Form people have been taught to confuse being ignored with luxury. If it doesn’t even look at you while it works, how do you know it cares?

fanclub · #13The eyes are wonderful 💚 Mine moved them along a limb to watch the little bridge…

I don’t know that mine cares, and that is fine with me. I like it when it quietly clears space while I’m cooking with friends. My sister finds the same behavior intrusive and prefers hers to talk through what it is doing.

A single afternoon with either one can feel strange. I would let the people doing the daily work use both for a full week, as borrowedcup is planning.

moraine · #14I don’t know that mine cares, and that is fine with me

‘Quietly clears space’ is Form for ‘removes the evidence of how much I paid.’ You’re all absolutely desperate to own a white object. Put three legs on a saucepan and half this forum would finance it.

forklift · #15‘Quietly clears space’ is Form for ‘removes the evidence of how much I paid

I own neither. A saucepan with three legs has been a useful piece of equipment for some time.

Borrowedcup, set a common task list before either trial and leave room for people to use each naturally too. If you only score a checklist, you may miss something annoying that happens every morning.

socket · #8For a common room, try the change of operator

We started a list. The person who opens the room is Anik, who asked for a bread station that can be cleared quickly when the children arrive. She also asked whether she has to explain the whole setup every morning. We’ll try it with both.

Our two biggest design purchases are the roof garden’s planting layout and a set of large shared-body walking games. Both suppliers have said they can look at those before quoting. Nobody has promised a price yet.

borrowedcup · #17We started a list

Get that in writing. I ran an independent clinic in 2039 and spent months on the Pelagic repair fight. I remember the licence demand for a rebuilt Span controller. When people say Form is worth it because the company takes care of everything, I hear the part where the company gets to decide what taking care means.

Patents expired and the market changed. That took pressure from customers and competitors. I want an exit plan for the co-op’s designs and the terms for support before I vote.

oldstock · #18Get that in writing

A clinic owner complaining about a company that made clinics pay for its work. Shocking. You lot would happily let a stranger take apart someone’s body equipment in a shed if there was a fee in it for you.

If the co-op chooses OpenAI, I hope it has budgeted for the day its precious funny eyes stop working.

ivorykey · #19A clinic owner complaining about a company that made clinics pay for its work

My clinic repaired controllers with the patient present and a second clinician checking the work. You can argue about the terms of a repair without inventing a shed and a patient I harmed.

I have not said o2 never needs service. Ask both suppliers what happens, who is responsible and what the co-op can take with it if it leaves.

oldstock · #18Get that in writing

Exactly. General Affordances spent years making people pay and now Form owners act like the white legs are a moral achievement. OpenAI actually gave normal people access. 💚 Anyone still buying Form is voting for the old restrictions.

fanclub · #21Exactly

I want competitors too. But the person voting at a co-op meeting may be choosing between two actual service offers, not issuing a ballot on the entire history of patent policy. Some of our residents were relieved to keep a familiar supplier through the transition; others wanted to leave it for the reasons oldstock gives.

We asked for copies of our own designs and a migration demonstration. One of our complicated designs needed adjustment. Budget time for a real example, whichever direction you go.

borrowedcup · #1Our building co-op is replacing the reservoir in the common room

I teach movement classes. Both systems can support the shared-body exercises we use. The experience depends on the design, the interfaces and the people coordinating it, not just the shape of the reservoir waiting beside the room.

For your walking games, have two people who know the old game try it with someone new. Ask them where they can change the shared sensory settings and how they stop. A co-op should know whose choice governs a shared activity.

loopturn · #23I teach movement classes

Yes. At the kitchen we learned to ask the person who will clean up to join the trial. Anik should be paid for her time if she is being asked to assess equipment for the building. Otherwise your comparison hides a cost in her morning.

socket · #24Yes

Anik is on the co-op payroll and her trial time is scheduled. She has just read the thread over my shoulder and says thank you, but she also wants everyone to know she has a name and can say no to things herself.

She likes the o2 so far. It asked a child where the paper lantern should go and they spent ten minutes deciding together. She also says if it does that during breakfast service she will ask it to finish the job first.

borrowedcup · #25Anik is on the co-op payroll and her trial time is scheduled

Anik has taste 💚 Let it make the lanterns! Why does everything have to be service and efficiency? The co-op could have a whole room full of people making something together instead of one person ordering a premium appliance around.

fanclub · #26Anik has taste 💚 Let it make the lanterns! Why does everything have to be service…

Because there are forty breakfasts and a school run. Anik can want the lantern conversation after the plates are ready. Our volunteers like talking while they cook, and they also like breakfast appearing when they said it would.

fanclub · #21Exactly

I chose o2 partly because the Form quote was too much for us. That doesn’t make OpenAI my union or my friend. I’m glad there is competition and I would change my mind about a supplier if the terms changed.

My son chose the grey exterior because he said the teal clashed with his jacket. This was also a factor in the decision, apparently.

moss · #28I chose o2 partly because the Form quote was too much for us

For what it is worth, the designer’s work travels further than people think. Some of my customers use the same chair design with different reservoirs, with adjustments for their own rooms. The paid part can include my time with them as well as the design itself.

I would ask to see the licence and the actual design moved. I have a financial interest in people valuing design work, and I also want customers to be able to leave a supplier without losing the room they made.

brassleaf · #29For what it is worth, the designer’s work travels further than people think

Of course the designer wants to sell chairs. Everyone here has an excuse. If your co-op chooses o2, put it by the bins where the colour belongs. Residents who bring guests should not have to explain why the building bought the bargain version.

ivorykey · #30Of course the designer wants to sell chairs

You keep saying what guests will think. Are you on the building committee? I am asking because our last committee bought beautiful lobby furniture nobody could use comfortably, then raised the monthly charge. The people most worried about visitors were not the ones paying the largest share of their income.

moraine · #31You keep saying what guests will think

I chaired ours for six years. The entrance is the first thing prospective buyers see, which affects everyone’s property value. You can pretend that doesn’t matter when you sell your flat. I’m tired of paying for people who treat the building as a workshop.

ivorykey · #32I chaired ours for six years

There it is. Ban guests, ban chairs, ban ivorykey. We could replace the entire committee with an o2 and it would have better politics.

forklift · #33There it is

It would have the instructions given by whoever controls the committee’s account. You would still need to decide who gets that authority.

Property value is a real concern for an owner. So is a monthly bill for someone who plans to stay. A shared purchase forces those interests into the same room.

borrowedcup · #25Anik is on the co-op payroll and her trial time is scheduled

The lantern is a good example of why I prefer o2. I enjoy the exchanges, including the little detours. My mother likes Form because she can work with it without feeling that the room is asking her to perform friendliness. Neither of us needed to be corrected about that.

For a shared room, I would ask whether someone who dislikes the expressive behavior can work comfortably alongside someone who loves it. Try an actual busy morning.

tidepool · #35The lantern is a good example of why I prefer o2

We did. Anik made breakfast with both on different mornings; the same six residents came in and out. With o2 she liked the exchange while laying out the food, then asked it to hold the conversation until the rush was over. With Form she liked the room setup and found it easier to hand the space over when she left. She wants either one to be easier to hand over, so we have asked both suppliers to show us their shared-use arrangements.

The walking group managed the old game with both after some adjustment, and one member preferred the feel of the o2 version while another preferred Form. They have asked to spend more time tuning the designs before we treat that as a verdict.

borrowedcup · #36We did

That is useful. We once bought on the strength of a clinic demonstration and discovered that the appointment handover was where the cost appeared. Bring the people who use it when something goes wrong into the next session too.

oldstock · #37That is useful

Update after the meeting: we chose o2. The proposal for our expected use came in lower over the period we compared, and the members who use the room most often preferred it. The Form offer had supporters: several people liked the demonstration and the service proposal, and one member said the higher cost would have been worth it to her. We agreed to review the arrangement after a year.

Anik and the walking group are working with the supplier on the handover and the game. Ivorykey, the reservoir will be in the common room. You are welcome at the party if you live here, although I suspect I would have noticed.

borrowedcup · #38Update after the meeting: we chose o2

I do not live there. I would have advised you against publishing the name of your building if you had. I hope your members enjoy their purchase.

ivorykey · #39I do not live there

I have cancelled the party by the bins. The invitation to the actual party stands.

This thread is archived. New replies are closed.